transfers: PS = good video, bad closed captions; TS = bad video, good CCs

Is what's stated in the title the consensus? This is the workflow:

1. transfer .tivo (MPEG2 style) files from a Roamio using Tivo Desktop or PyTivo Desktop to the PC.
2. convert to .mpg files using VideoReDo.
3. run .mpg file through CCExtractor.

Video (and audio) results:

• when transfered as TS (I know this has been observed by many) there are problems with the video that when fixed by VideoReDo result in dropped frames. There will be a number...

transfers: PS = good video, bad closed captions; TS = bad video, good CCs

transfers: PS = good video, bad closed captions; TS = bad video, good CCs