Tivo Suggestions - SD/HD

When I received my Bolt last week, the Tivo Suggestions feature worked out fairly well (was even better since I started rating shows). The only issue was it kept defaulting to the SD versions of all the channels. To remedy this issue, I deselected all of the SD channels that had HD equivalents from the ISP.

Now, my Bolt will still record suggestions, but only on the non HD channels still. I tried disabling Tivo Suggestions -> Reboot -> Enable Suggestions -> Reboot, but the issue persists.

Is this working as intended, or should I try something else to get it to record on HD channels?

Thanks.